Rethinking Marine Conservation

A recent study, led by the University of Queensland's Professor Anthony Richardson, challenges conventional wisdom regarding marine conservation and the escalating human-induced damage to the world's oceans. Termed the 'blue acceleration,' the increasing impact of industrial activities in marine areas beyond national jurisdictions has prompted a diverse range of stakeholders to reevaluate current marine protection methods.

The research focuses on addressing the rapid decline of marine biodiversity caused by the expansion of activities like fishing, shipping, and deep-sea mining in areas beyond national jurisdictions (ABNJ). The study introduces a cross-sectoral approach to marine protection, aiming to strike a balance between conservation targets and profitable human activities.

By assessing different networks of marine protection areas (MPA) in the Indian Ocean, researchers aimed to identify rich biodiversity areas with minimal impact on various sectors. Three sector-specific plans, involving fishing, shipping, and mining separately, were created to determine optimal locations for strict, no-take MPAs. A cross-sectoral no-take plan, considering the overall impact on all stakeholders, was then developed and compared with the sector-specific solutions.

The key finding challenges conventional approaches, revealing that the cross-sectoral plan meets conservation targets at significantly lower additional costs for each stakeholder. For instance, the fishing sector would lose only 20% of potential revenue under the cross-sectoral plan, compared to a staggering 54% under the simultaneous implementation of all sector-specific plans without coordination. Similar positive outcomes were observed for the shipping and mining sectors.

Moreover, the study suggests that the size of MPAs can be reduced from 25% to 8% of the spatial plan while achieving the same conservation objectives. This approach aligns with the recently signed United Nations High Seas Treaty, offering a potential solution to minimise conflicts between conservationists and various industries.

The research provides a code that can be accessed online and applied globally, offering a tool for scientists, conservationists, and policymakers. The ultimate goal is to not only reduce conflicts but also ensure the simultaneous protection of marine life against the negative cumulative impacts of multiple industries. Despite these findings, skepticism remains, emphasising the need for ongoing critical evaluation and discussion in the pursuit of sustainable marine conservation.

Read more here