The Financial Toll of Nature Mismanagement

In collaboration with the Taskforce on Nature-related Financial Disclosures (TNFD), BloombergNEF (BNEF) has delved into the financial repercussions faced by companies due to poorly managed interactions with nature. Examining ten instances of substantial financial losses, BNEF highlights the diverse nature-related risks that all sectors face, directly or indirectly, as economic activities depend on natural capital and its associated ecosystem services.

Three Categories of Nature-Related Risks:

1. Physical Risk and Nature-Related Dependencies:

Bernard Matthews, a UK-based poultry producer, suffered brand damage and significant financial losses when lax biosecurity measures led to avian influenza outbreaks.

Tesla faced operational delays and share price falls as its Berlin-Brandenburg gigafactory construction was hindered by environmental concerns.

2. Transition Risk from Company Impacts on Nature:

Companies like 3M, Formosa, and Freeport-McMoRan faced legal and policy risks by releasing harmful materials into watercourses, resulting in over $10 billion in legal liabilities.

Container shipping company CMA CGM received penalties due to ballast water treatment infringements, reflecting the broader transition risks concerning water resources.

3. Overlap between Nature and Climate Risk:

PG&E, a California utility, filed for bankruptcy after being held liable for wildfires caused by failing to maintain power lines in drought-affected forest regions.

Other US utilities, like PacifiCorp, Xcel Energy, and Hawaiian Electric, are grappling with legal and reputational losses related to wildfires.

The Interconnected Nature and Climate Risk: The text underscores the interconnectedness of nature and climate risks, emphasizing the impact of temperature extremes, droughts, and other climate-related phenomena on ecosystem services. Shifts in land and ocean use, primary drivers of nature loss, contribute significantly to climate change, reinforcing the need for integrated risk management.

The Financial Cost to Companies and the Economy: BNEF's analysis reveals that the financial toll of nature mismanagement varies, ranging from six-figure fines to substantial settlements like 3M's $10 billion agreement. Share price declines, such as Tesla's 3% intraday drop and PG&E's over 90% decline, demonstrate the gravity of nature-related risks.

A Glimpse into the Future: As nature's decline accelerates, nature risk is becoming increasingly material to companies across sectors. The World Bank's "Economic Case for Nature" predicts a 2.3% fall in global GDP by 2030 under a partial ecosystem collapse scenario, amounting to $2.7 trillion.

The findings underscore the urgency for companies to integrate nature-related risks into their strategies, emphasizing the need for responsible interactions with nature to safeguard both ecosystems and corporate financial stability.

Read about it here